top of page

Navigating AI with a Discerning Mind: Strategies for Assessing AI Tools and Their Results

I'm still riding the wave of excitement about AI (my doctorate is in educational technology), and I imagine this incredible journey is going to carry on for quite some time! I was in Bali in January 2023 when one of the technology teachers showed me the power of ChatGPT. It's not just a tech revolution; it's a chance to really shake things up in how we teach and learn. #AIPoweredPedagogy


In today's digital age, the use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools has become increasingly prevalent in academic settings. We need to be conscious of guiding our students to use AI tools with a critical eye. Take an instance from my master's class: one group used an AI tool to summarize a lengthy PDF but found inaccuracies in the results. I had to remind them that they could refine and correct the AI-generated response! Meanwhile, other groups had already taken the initiative to enhance, edit, and verify the facts in their summaries. It's important to remember that the skill to scrutinize and improve AI-generated content isn't always second nature, even for university students. As students and educators engage with AI-generated content, it is essential to cultivate the skill of critically evaluating and editing these outputs. (Please see my blog post about prompt development as an iterative conversation here)


I don’t think I need to convince anyone that understanding the critical role of analytical thinking within AI literacy is essential. It emphasizes the necessity for students to engage in thoughtful reflection and examination of their academic work to maintain integrity. Moreover, it underpins the importance of assessing the AI tools and resources utilized to ensure they meet academic standards.


Newcastle University provides valuable resources to support this endeavor, including the "Critical Evaluation of AI Tools" checklist. This checklist serves as a guide to help users think critically and make informed judgments about the AI tools they choose to use. It covers aspects such as reliability, type, objective, bias, and owner of the AI technology, enabling individuals to assess the ethical and responsible use of these tools.


Additionally, the website offers downloadable resources, including the "Six questions critical evaluation checklist," which further aids in critically evaluating online information generated by AI. These resources are invaluable in fostering AI literacy and encouraging individuals to approach AI tools and outputs with a discerning mindset.


By engaging with these critical questions, users can make well-informed decisions about the AI tools they choose to utilize, ensuring that they do so ethically and responsibly.


Moreover, the website emphasizes the importance of maintaining good academic practice and integrity when using AI tools. It underscores the need for students to critically evaluate AI-generated content and appropriately acknowledge its use in their work. This aligns with the overarching principle of academic integrity, which requires students to demonstrate independent learning, research, and critical thinking while respecting the work of others.


As AI technologies continue to advance and integrate into various aspects of academic life, it is crucial for students and educators to develop the necessary skills to engage with these tools thoughtfully. The resources provided by Newcastle University's Academic Skills Kit offer practical guidance for approaching AI-generated information critically and ethically. By leveraging these resources, individuals can enhance their AI literacy and contribute to a culture of responsible and informed use of AI tools in educational settings.


In conclusion, instilling a robust framework of analytical and critical thinking is paramount in the realm of AI literacy. As AI technology becomes increasingly integrated into our educational landscape, the ability to critically evaluate and ethically employ these tools is crucial. Students and educators alike must be adept at not only understanding the mechanics of AI but also at scrutinizing the validity and reliability of its outputs. Developing these competencies ensures that as we harness the power of AI, we are also safeguarding the intellectual rigor and authenticity of our scholarly endeavors.


Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
bottom of page